In case you didn’t see it, Graham Hancock appeared on Russell Brand’s podcast this past week to promote Ancient Apocalypse and to attack archaeologists yet again for being mean to him by asking for evidence for his claims. Hancock looks tired and angry during the interview, and even Brand notes that he seems unduly dejected and downtrodden for a man with one of the world’s most popular streaming nonfiction series. During the interview Brand complains, not wholly incorrectly, that without Hancock only “elites” have access to archaeology. That’s true, but not because the public needs Atlantis to be interested but because the mainstream media only patronize sensational claims and Hancock’s hated “academics” have retreated into a bubble created by universities’ publish-or-perish mentality, hyper-specialization, and academic publishers exploitative pricing that essentially disincentivizes public engagement. Popularizers certainly have a role to play, but not one that should involve making things up.
Throughout the half-hour podcast Hancock appears grumpy and sad and says he needs “a cuddle” after attacks from critics. Again, Hancock complains about “schools,” “academia,” and “the education system,” and it’s very clear that he is remembering his own school days since he describes the teaching of a “linear” model of “progress” from caveman to computer than hasn’t been taught since the 1960s. (At root, he’s describing the old Victorian model of progress from “savagery” to “barbarism” to “civilization,” long recognized as flawed.) Hancock alleges that archaeologists have immense “power” and “despise” the public. This is related to his claim that they serve as guardians of an official past and talk down to anyone who challenges some agreed-upon “narrative,” presumably enshrined in a catechism in the Smithsonian to which every archaeologist must swear an oath of allegiance before picking up a trowel. Hancock, for the first time I recall, announces that there is “a huge amount of evidence for reincarnation,” and then he becomes very upset that “mainstream scientists attack my work” by citing his claims about Atlantean psychic telekinesis in America Before, which he says shouldn’t count against him because they take up but one page. That’s an odd way of looking at one’s own work. Hancock bitterly resents critics noting his drug use, but he only discusses ayahuasca in this context. He purposely claims not to have taken “cocaine” in order to elide his own admission that he was a heavy user of marijuana and that the drug had made him paranoid and impacted his work. Those were his words, and now he carefully talks around them. He finished the podcast by claiming that modern civilization is “doomed” and that a self-induced apocalypse is coming due to partisan rancor and capitalist destruction of planetary resources. In short, he walks right up to the edge of admitting that it doesn’t matter whether his story about a lost civilization is factually true because it serves as a mythic warning about contemporary society, one that he sees “elites”—meaning those who currently operate the control mechanisms of modern life—trying to suppress to keep the wheels of capitalism turning. Again, it’s an odd choice for someone who became a jet-setting multimillionaire from the media, one of the most successful capitalist enterprises of the past century.
61 Comments
Thoroughly debunked
1/11/2023 11:25:14 am
Graham Hancock was easily and thoroughly debunked by the BBC documentary "Atlantis Reborn" in 2000 and showing a snip in a repeat of the documentary that Hancock groaned about did not change the conclusion about him. And since 2000 Hancock, like Erich Von Daniken, has not stopped spamming with his "popcorn archaeology" for the gullible crowds.
Reply
Naughtius
1/11/2023 12:43:25 pm
Russel Brand was always a bit of a plonker, he had his fair share of the drugs back in the day when he was presenter on British tv.
Reply
Jim
1/11/2023 01:28:51 pm
As far as marijuana goes, it is widely thought that the sativa strains are the ones that cause paranoia. I would recommend Hancock smoke a very strong indica strain. The benefits are twofold:
Reply
Kent
1/11/2023 11:17:45 pm
“The idea that one plant phenotype expression causes different effects, i.e. sativa is always energetic, indica is always relaxing, is not based on scientific evidence.”
Reply
Kent
1/13/2023 09:20:55 pm
Uh, not the Kent who is often taken to task for being Joe Scales and legions of others.
Jim
1/14/2023 10:15:50 am
Further to my point vis-à-vis sativa traits vs. indigo traits, it should be noted that some stoners and argumentative types may confuse the multitude of mixed parentage strains (sativa and indica strains that have been crossbred ) with actual sativa and indica strains.
Reply
AAA
1/11/2023 02:47:47 pm
Both Hancock and science fundamentalists could find Elena Danaan's book The Seeders: The Return Of The Gods interesting.
Reply
Rock Knocker
1/12/2023 06:47:57 pm
Or, they could just chuck it in the bin where it belongs. I weep for the future of science….
Reply
Crash55
1/11/2023 06:48:19 pm
I disagree with the only elites have access comments. There are many general public magazines, websites, and newsletters available. I subscribe to Smithsonian, National Geographic, Current World Archaeology and Archaeology at present. At times I have also read American Archaeology and Biblical Archaeology. These magazines are no more expensive than your average magazine.
Reply
Doc Rock
1/14/2023 10:51:45 am
I used to give students mini-workshops on how to get textbooks cheaply instead of buying new at the university bookstore. In some cases, for example, there is little substantive difference in the 5th and 8th edition of particular books. Had students that bought the older editions online for maybe 1/4 of the original price. Think I had one student get a formerly 50 dollar book for one dollar online. Still trying to figure out why people even bother to sell something online for a buck. But then again I had students complain bitterly about paying 90 bucks for a primary text while driving a car most junior faculty couldn't afford and racking up enormous bar tabs drinking the good stuff on any given Friday eve, Priorities.
Reply
Crash55
1/14/2023 05:55:42 pm
The only problem with that is if the professor assigns HW out of the textbook. Quite often different version have different problem sets
Doc Rock
1/22/2023 09:42:04 am
My homework assignments weren't driven by study questions in textbooks. So that never came up as an issue for me. Could be a problem for others though, if one got into significant variation across editions of a text.
Paul
1/12/2023 12:26:50 am
Archaeologists are “normal” people.
Reply
The Real Mystery
1/12/2023 03:34:28 pm
How did a homeless looking Brit with resting constipation face land Katy Perry?
Reply
Tommy Gunn
9/20/2023 02:14:36 am
He's sexy to women, and you're not (or, if you're a woman, don't be jealous).
Reply
Matt
1/12/2023 05:51:14 pm
The comments on that YouTube video are really eye opening. A reminder as to why I don't engage much with social media anymore, just a bunch of people throwing out opinions on things they have no idea on. The blind scamming the blind as it were. I have a friend who sends through Russell Brand video links occasionally and I'm pretty happy with my strategy of just deleting them :-)
Reply
E.P. Grondine
1/12/2023 06:43:47 pm
Hi Jason -
Reply
Kent
1/13/2023 09:35:32 pm
"Hi Jason -
Reply
E.P. Grondine
1/18/2023 12:41:06 pm
Sorry about the misspellings -I had a stroke.
Kent
1/21/2023 12:36:47 am
You didn't have a stroke you had an excuse.
E.P. Grondine
1/21/2023 02:43:02 pm
Hi Kent -
Kent
1/21/2023 11:36:02 pm
Oh, Mr. Grenadine.
Kent
1/14/2023 02:26:00 pm
Here noted astrophysicist E.P. Grondine blows minds by revealing that the Maunder Minimum, a period of cooler than usual weather on Earth was caused by Jupiter's gravity tamping down the fusion process in the Sun.
Reply
E.P. Grondine
1/21/2023 02:49:36 pm
Kent, I have never written about the Maunder Minnimum.
E.P. Grondine
1/21/2023 03:35:33 pm
First off, I want to thank Jason for allowing me to use his blog to post on these personal matters.
Kent
1/21/2023 11:48:51 pm
"Kent, I have never written about the Maunder Minnimum."
E.P. Grondine
1/25/2023 06:08:53 pm
Kent, the link you cite is not working.
Kent
1/25/2023 09:12:04 pm
I would hate to be so feeble that links don't work for me. One hopes at least that toilet paper works for you.
Paul
1/22/2023 12:54:44 pm
Eddie, you do realize that your nonsense barely rises to being bad fiction, much less having any scientific or historical value. Even less so for any claims of primacy.
Reply
E.P. Grondine
1/28/2023 01:30:51 pm
Hi Paul -
Doc Rock
1/12/2023 09:54:19 pm
Compared to the price of a new edition of Hancock's latest book, the pricing of various popularly oriented books on archaeology ranging from archaeology for dummies to Fagan's works are reasonable. Using google scholar one can access various articles in archaeology as well as other topics like Younger Dryas Impact Hypothesis for free. Even a lot of initially overpriced textbooks are affordable for the careful online shopper. I would lean toward media hype and the overall appeal of lost civilizations, new age spirituality, wacky tobbacky and DMT tripping, and conspiracy theory as the driving force(s) for why Hancock is a millionaire celeb. Not so much the inaccessibility of academic work across the board.
Reply
E.P. Grondine
1/18/2023 12:53:57 pm
Hi Doc -
Reply
E.P. Grondine
1/13/2023 05:02:51 pm
You may or may not believe this, but I may have been the person responsible for informing Hancock about the comet impact that killed off the mammoth, Three years ago at a public event at Serpent Mound after he spoke there.
Reply
Paul
1/13/2023 11:14:58 pm
That bs was around long before you, Eddy. But then you do live in a fantasy world…..
Reply
E.P. Grondine
1/18/2023 12:47:14 pm
Hi Paul -
E.P. Grondine
1/19/2023 10:58:56 am
Hi Paul -
E.P. Grondine
1/20/2023 12:32:55 pm
Hi Paul -
An Over-Educated Grunt
1/19/2023 12:56:16 pm
I feel like this post should become a thing.
Reply
Jim
1/21/2023 01:46:07 am
Believe it or not,,,, I agree with you.
Kent
1/21/2023 03:08:35 am
You may or may not believe this but I may have been the one who invented.sticks.
Paul
1/21/2023 11:27:23 am
Well, Ernie,
Reply
E.P. Grondine
1/21/2023 02:23:30 pm
Thanks for the link - there was another kraut working on impact early on whose name escapes me right now - see my note in the Cambridge Conference archive on him.
Kent
1/22/2023 12:25:20 pm
Okay so no info on impact and gamma rays? So you're a complete idiot, that's fine. I don't judge. Let's assume it happens. If you don't provide information, that's a problem.
Kent
1/22/2023 10:22:54 pm
@ Paul: Except for the b2theM Mr. Grondine has never brought up anything.
Jim
1/14/2023 04:04:47 pm
Breaking News:
Reply
Brian
1/15/2023 09:12:30 am
Hancock AND Brand in a one-on-one? It's astounding the universe didn't implode into a black hole of dementia.
Reply
Jim
1/17/2023 09:36:04 am
Heinrich Himmler corroborates Graham Hancock's work.
Reply
E.P. Grondine
1/21/2023 02:13:48 pm
Hi Jim -
Reply
Jim
1/22/2023 08:15:06 am
Link works for me.
Kent
1/22/2023 05:07:54 pm
I'm not surprised at that. In your personal life do you kill Jews for sport or food or both? My view is it's hardly sporting and I haven't reached the point where cannibalism seems like an option. But hey, different people, different state laws, last time I checked I don't run the world. Pretty confident about that last bit. But I do read zero to no books every day.
Paul
1/23/2023 11:28:01 pm
Eddie,
E.P. Grondine
1/26/2023 04:34:26 pm
E.P. Grondine
1/26/2023 04:43:53 pm
Hi Paul -
Paul
1/27/2023 09:41:50 am
Here is your shit. Probably find it less someplace else, like in the trash.
Kent
1/27/2023 09:01:50 pm
"E.P. GRONDINE
E.P. Grondine
1/25/2023 06:17:17 pm
Hi Paul - As of June 2002
Reply
Paul
1/25/2023 10:22:44 pm
Odd, most of these citations that are accessible are for air bursts. Three, you are citing yourself, which are garbage. A couple apparently refer to lightning. Most of the rest are broken links. Campo was probably an air burst with many multiple fragments, in fact,I have a small one.
Reply
E.P. Grondine
1/26/2023 04:40:54 pm
Hi Paul -
Kent
1/27/2023 05:00:38 pm
"Rafinesque had an interesting epitaph about not letting the bastards getting you down inscribed on his tombstone If you are in Lexington, be sure to visit it."
Reply
E.P. Grondine
1/30/2023 01:50:32 pm
https://lextoday.6amcity.com/the-curse-of-constantine-rafinesque-lexington-ky
Reply
ralphie Hunter
2/12/2023 12:06:21 am
jason, brand doesnt look that great either. and please post a picture of yourself, so we can see it meets our expectations of what a successful blogger should look like.
Reply
Your comment will be posted after it is approved.
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorI am an author and researcher focusing on pop culture, science, and history. Bylines: New Republic, Esquire, Slate, etc. There's more about me in the About Jason tab. Newsletters
Enter your email below to subscribe to my newsletter for updates on my latest projects, blog posts, and activities, and subscribe to Culture & Curiosities, my Substack newsletter.
Categories
All
Terms & ConditionsPlease read all applicable terms and conditions before posting a comment on this blog. Posting a comment constitutes your agreement to abide by the terms and conditions linked herein.
Archives
December 2024
|