Historians, archaeologists, and skeptics of all stripes quickly condemned the History Channel for using the language of racial inclusivity, diversity, and justice while simultaneously airing programming that sends exactly the opposite message.
The History Channel is the current home of Ancient Aliens, a program that has spent ten years asserting that the world’s native and indigenous people were unable to construct monuments or develop cultures of their own without extraterrestrial help. While the series occasionally mentions alien help for Europeans, it is in terms of partnership or white appropriation of alien technology, while non-whites are described as overwhelmed by and submissive to alien overlords. The History Channel and its former second channel H2 aired many seasons of programs like America Unearthed which claimed that Native people were not the true indigenous occupants of the Americas but had replaced a lost white race originating in Europe. The History Channel has aired many programs, including America Unearthed and Search for the Lost Giants, that alleged Native Americans were the hybrid descendants of a lost white race, the latter show asserting that this lost race was physically superior. Its highest-rated show, The Curse of Oak Island, claimed that Native peoples worshiped white Europeans as living gods. The History Channel has aired many programs, including Ancient Aliens, In Search Of, and many one-off specials, alleging that global indigenous cultures originated on Atlantis, a Greek-style lost civilization occupied by a lost white race. Such stories were based on Ignatius Donnelly’s Atlantis: The Antediluvian World, which specifically identified Atlantis’s people as white. The History Channel and its spinoff channel have given platforms to so-called “experts” who have made either explicit or implicit racist, xenophobic, homophobic, and anti-Semitic claims. One program, for example, praised Jan Van Helsing, a neo-Nazi sympathizer, for his claims about Nazi UFOs. Several of their hosts have, in their tie-in books or literary work, relied on racist material. Scott Wolter, in the book he published while a History Channel host, endorsed the work of fascist sympathizer and racist Jacques de Mahieu. Erich von Däniken of Ancient Aliens has repeatedly made offensive comments about black people, women, and Muslims. He once suggested that aliens invented white people because the black race was a “failure,” albeit a “musical” one. The History Channel programs, especially Ancient Aliens, glorify the Nazis, routinely depicting them as possessed of supernatural power, having direct access to occult and extraterrestrial forces, and lying in wait to restore order to a chaotic world. America Unearthed explicitly claimed that Americans “have to admire” Confederate terrorists who attempt to spread white supremacy and slavery to Latin America. The History Channel frequently features anti-Catholic conspiracy theories about nefarious Vatican coverups of the “truth” about Jesus, aliens, and God, recycling early Protestant attacks on Catholicism, a religion disproportionately associated with immigrants and Hispanic/Latin people. The History Channel does not feature any African American hosts for its current slate of history-themed programming. To the best of my knowledge, they have not had a woman host a history-focused series, though I believe they had a woman on a couple of their reality game shows. In short, the History Channel wants credit for sounding woke while profiting from old systems of structural racism that have been inherent in the fringe history genre for two centuries. I talked about this in my recent book The Mound Builder Myth, which documents the systemic racism behind America’s relationship to ancient American history and the perverse effects it had on science, scholarship, and, most importantly, relations with racial minorities.
19 Comments
Joe Scales
6/3/2020 10:23:57 am
So you don't want them to change then?
Reply
MOMUS
6/3/2020 02:36:08 pm
It's not like you have to want everybody. Some people may have redeeming qualities underneath the things you would like to change. Some other people you just want to f... off.
Reply
gdave
6/3/2020 05:11:04 pm
I don't want to speak for Jason, but, personally, yeah, I'd like to see History channel change. And maybe the recent Grant documentary is the tip of the iceberg, and we're going to see a wave of high-quality documentaries, and not just of U.S. Presidents, but of other historical figures like Harriet Tubman and Frederick Douglas.
Reply
Kent
6/3/2020 05:36:16 pm
Would you be happy with Black pseudo-experts? Would an episode on the Mad Scientist Yakub who supposedly created white people work for you?
Clete
6/4/2020 09:07:46 am
Talking about the latest offering by the History Channel "Grant". I gave up on it about an hour in (actually it was probably only about twenty minutes of program, interrupted by at least eight thousand six hundred and forty-six commercials. Then a recap and repeated scenes of what had been shown}. History Channel is a long, long way from making anything of quality and anything having any real depth.
Joe Scales
6/4/2020 10:24:18 am
Well, they did gloss over the whole Grant/Alien thing...
An Anonymous Nerd
6/5/2020 07:28:18 am
The Charge of the Fringe Brigade continues, I see.
Reply
Joe Scales
6/5/2020 03:04:41 pm
Again with the insults; and mind-bogglingly inaccurate with them as is your creed. At this point, it's actually rather amusing that you continue to believe that I am somehow in league with this Fringe and come here with some coordinated plan of attack. You've said it before, and by your comments today, apparently it still stands. Your own conspiracy theory.
Kent
6/3/2020 11:41:38 am
Sadly this article depends on a false dichotomy between "White Europeans" (like the ones who built Stonehenge with alien help?) and "Native and indigenous peoples" which is frankly racist.
Reply
Pharoh Menses
6/3/2020 05:34:42 pm
More like he reports on a false racist dichotomy perpetuated by patently racist statements by the likes of EVD. Big difference there Mr. Sickle Cell only attacks people that look like Morgan Freeman.
Reply
Crash55
6/3/2020 12:14:31 pm
You are talking about actually standing for equality amongst all peoples. That is not what any company truly cares about at present. They just care about paying lip service to the current protesters so that they don’t find themselves on the wrong side of a boycott or Molotov cocktail.
Reply
aaa
6/4/2020 04:09:48 am
Equality amongst all people is obviously impossible.
Reply
Crash55
6/4/2020 10:42:34 am
That depends upon how you define equality. Yes it will be hard but it is the goal. That was the idea of the Federation in Star Trek.
A really nasty TV channel.
Reply
Bob Jase
6/4/2020 11:09:40 am
Its hard to believe a channel once nicknamed 'The Hitler Channel' could become more racist after dropping its Hitler shows but it managed.
Reply
Martin Stower
6/4/2020 03:32:40 pm
Stefan Erdmann’s sometime co-author “Jan van Helsing” is, as we know, Jan Udo Holey.
Reply
Adam W
6/6/2020 01:06:56 am
Hypocrisy Channel.
Reply
Martin Stower
6/7/2020 05:40:03 am
They have dropped the “Channel”: it is simply Hypocrisy.
Reply
Nobu naga
6/10/2020 01:30:42 pm
The history channel should do what every other channel does. Try to make money. I don’t care what they aire. You guys all wish you lived in a dystopian future. It’s hilarious.
Reply
Your comment will be posted after it is approved.
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorI am an author and researcher focusing on pop culture, science, and history. Bylines: New Republic, Esquire, Slate, etc. There's more about me in the About Jason tab. Newsletters
Enter your email below to subscribe to my newsletter for updates on my latest projects, blog posts, and activities, and subscribe to Culture & Curiosities, my Substack newsletter.
Categories
All
Terms & ConditionsPlease read all applicable terms and conditions before posting a comment on this blog. Posting a comment constitutes your agreement to abide by the terms and conditions linked herein.
Archives
September 2024
|