In a recent podcast appearance, UFO advocate and media personality Lue Elizondo explained his reasoning behind claiming that UFO mysteries have made him "somber." His speculative ideas are straight out of middle twentieth century science fiction, particularly the so-called "zoo hypothesis" that appeared in a number of stories at that time, imagining that Earth was essentially a zoo run by space aliens. This is an outgrowth of Charles Fort's claim that some non-human intelligence essentially operates Earth as a prison or an ant farm to watch us, and it is the basis for the "prison planet" claims of some contemporary ancient astronaut theorists. I transcribe here Elizondo's comments for posterity so there will be a written record of them the next time someone needs evidence of his sci-fi inflected speculation. “What if it turns out that there’s another species that is even higher on that ladder than we are? Do we need the social institutions that we have today, do we need government and religious organizations that we have today, if it turns out that there is something else or someone else that is technologically more advanced and, perhaps from an evolutionary perspective, more advanced? Have we been wasting our time all this time? Or are we doing exactly as we are supposed to be doing? Note the distinct echo of Christian millenarianism in Elizondo's suggestion that the existence of aliens would require an overthrow of social, political, and cultural structures in favor of a new, more utopian world submissive to a superior heavenly power. It is difficult not to see his imagined Disclosure as the Christian Apocalypse of Revelation recast in secular, pseudoscientific terms.
8 Comments
11/28/2021 02:22:41 pm
Nothing new under the sun. I do find congressional acquiescence to this nonsense disturbing, however.
Reply
11/16/2023 06:29:39 pm
Woah ! I heard the exact opposite ! I was actually HOPING he’d imply what you describe, but oh contraire ! I think Lue INCLUDED religion in his list of societal foundations that will need to be “re-written”; and nowhere did he mention God OR Heaven. I was hoping he WOULD allude to the possibility that ATHEISTS would have to rethink their beliefs, but he didn’t. You have erroneously misread Mr Elizando views.
Reply
Kent
11/28/2021 07:25:42 pm
" It is difficult not to see his imagined Disclosure as the Christian Apocalypse of Revelation recast in secular, pseudoscientific terms."
Reply
apostle obvious
12/6/2021 01:40:16 pm
Judeo-Christian tradition is often simplified into modern christian tradition with associated concepts. It isn't really a difficult concept to follow unless you have being doing shots with Doc Rock.
Reply
Kent
12/8/2021 12:45:05 pm
The truckling implicit in the term "Judeo-Christian" has always bothered me.
Aachen
11/29/2021 03:08:49 pm
Unsurprising that the “thinker” doesn’t seem to understand evolution—[i]Pokemon[/i], perhaps, is among the speculative fiction into which he leans? :)
Reply
David Evans
12/1/2021 07:32:09 am
Contact with a culture perceived to be superior and more powerful will often bring major change, justified or not. I don't see that this idea is necessarily religious or apocalyptic. Aliens, if they exist, come from space, that doesn't make them heavenly.
Reply
Eric
12/1/2021 12:12:12 pm
Since the time of Verne and Wells, science fiction has consistently anticipated most important scientific discoveries. Discrediting ideas on the basis of their being "sci-fi inflected speculation" would be an enormous blow to scientific advancement.
Reply
Your comment will be posted after it is approved.
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorI am an author and researcher focusing on pop culture, science, and history. Bylines: New Republic, Esquire, Slate, etc. There's more about me in the About Jason tab. Newsletters
Enter your email below to subscribe to my newsletter for updates on my latest projects, blog posts, and activities, and subscribe to Culture & Curiosities, my Substack newsletter.
Categories
All
Terms & ConditionsPlease read all applicable terms and conditions before posting a comment on this blog. Posting a comment constitutes your agreement to abide by the terms and conditions linked herein.
Archives
November 2024
|