A little while back I posted on Andrew Collins’ claim that the constellation of Cygnus was (a) known to Paleolithic people, (b) assumed by them to be the source of cosmic radiation, and (c) the subject of a 35,000 year cult dedicated to the same. I’ve received some criticism for failing to address the complex web of assumptions Collins uses to support his belief that Cygnus was known in Paleolithic times and treated as an object of veneration.
This web of interlocking assumptions becomes rather complicated, but Collins bases his claims about Paleolithic stars on the conclusions of Michael Rappenglück (also spelled Rappenglueck), a professor at Munich University with a degree in the history of astronomy, who suggested in 2000 that dark circles painted in the Lascaux cave 20,000 years ago represented stars. This is not unreasonable, and many archaeologists who have reviewed Rappenglück’s claims say that he has made a good case. Not everyone, however, agrees with his wider conclusions that such star depictions form a calendar or a cosmology.
Rappenglück identified specific painted circles with specific star in the night sky, including the specific cave painting Collins cites as proof that Cygnus was known and venerated—the image of a bird on a stick, which appears in a grouping with a birdman and a bull. The eye of the bird on the stick, Rappenglück said, was the star Deneb, a prominent star now in the Cygnus constellation. However, Rappenglück does not state that the Paleolithic people identified this star (singular) with a complete constellation—the many stars of modern Cygnus were not depicted, unlike the more complete depiction of the Pleiades group in the same cave, for example. Instead, he suggests only one star from this grouping, Deneb, was depicted, along with Vega (as the eye in the abutting Bull drawing) and Altair (as the eye in the birdman drawing).
Rappenglück attributed no special meaning to Deneb’s appearance on the Lascaux cave wall. It was, he noted, one of the brightest stars in the sky. The complete “Ice Age star map,” as he identified it, was not necessarily a mystical catalogue for the ages (though he thinks it is) but rather a depiction of the brightest circumpolar stars—drawn from the whole sky, not just one constellation. In terms of sheer numbers, the Pleiades, being multiple in number, seem to have attracted more attention than the single star of Deneb, and Vega, housed in the largest drawing—the bull—is much more prominent than Deneb.
Needless to say, the selection of stars (except for the Pleiades) does not conform to the form of the constellations known from historical times (which Rappenglück specifically notes in his work), nor is it possible to prove that the image of the bird used in Lascaux has a direct connection to the avian form given to Cygnus more than 15,000 years later. (Indeed, birds are among the most common shapes for constellations worldwide—next to Cygnus is Aquila the eagle, for example. Birds live in the sky and are an appropriate image for sky-dwellers, and Rappenglück makes no claim of connection to the modern constellation.) None of the other constellation identifications, such as the bull (now in the constellation Lyra) or the birdman (now in the constellation Aquila) survive. As I previously noted, the seated, short-necked bird in profile on the Lascaux wall bears no resemblance to the spread-eagle avian form of either ancient or modern forms of the constellation.
Rappenglück’s analysis proves nothing more than that Paleolithic people observed the circumpolar stars of their era and drew them on Lascaux’s walls. This is no different than ancient people did at any time or any place, and it does not require the logical leap of assuming a continuity of belief—much less one focused on one set of stars not emphasized above any other—across tens of thousands of years. And since all people in all places have access to (more or less, depending on your exact location) the same stars, there is also no reason to posit imaginary connections between cultures based on a shared Paleolithic love of Cygnus.
I know of no myth, belief, or practice that can be traced back unbroken to Paleolithic times. No god or hero goes back much farther than the Bronze Age in direct testimony, and no further than 4500 BCE or so in scholarly reconstructions (the reconstructed Indo-European pantheon). It will take much more than a couple of pictures of birds to demonstrate a coherent continuity of belief across anywhere from twenty to thirty thousand years of history.
terry the censor
10/14/2012 08:55:30 am
> Rappenglück does not state that the Paleolithic people identified this star (singular) with a complete constellation—the many stars of modern Cygnus were not depicted
10/14/2012 09:14:01 am
I'm pretty sure Little is referring to Rappenglueck's work, with Collins interpolating the synecdoche of Deneb for Cygnus as a whole.
terry the censor
10/14/2012 09:34:25 am
You're unfailingly civil, Jason!
2/17/2014 01:47:33 pm
Thanks for the comments on my book "The Cygnus Mystery". My précis of Michael Rappenglück's work is sufficient, and was discussed with him before publication. I stand by his findings, and my confirmation of the same. The whole matter of Cygnus being known in the Upper Paleolithic is dealt with again in new book Gobekli Tepe: Genesis of the Gods (Bear & Co, 2014). I think you will find it of interest.
3/15/2016 11:58:32 am
I have the answers to Easter Island The Pyramids and the ram bull Osiris and the lion at https://plus.google.com/101274211048910084228
Your comment will be posted after it is approved.
Leave a Reply.
I am an author and researcher focusing on pop culture, science, and history. Bylines: New Republic, Esquire, Slate, etc. There's more about me in the About Jason tab.
Enter your email below to subscribe to my newsletter for updates on my latest projects, blog posts, and activities, and subscribe to Culture & Curiosities, my Substack newsletter.
Terms & Conditions
Please read all applicable terms and conditions before posting a comment on this blog. Posting a comment constitutes your agreement to abide by the terms and conditions linked herein.