In its quest to be all things to all people, Netflix releases a lot of content that wouldn’t make the cut at most networks. This filler tends to get dumped on off days, or in the shadow of higher-profile series. October Faction, nominally a supernatural monster-hunting drama, premiered just one day before the release of the next batch of episodes of the similarly themed Chilling Adventures of Sabrina, and Netflix made it quite clear that October Faction was a dud. The show, filmed more than a year ago, dropped on a weekday with virtually no promotion, and for good reason. It’s bad, at least based on the first half of the season, which was as far as I got before I couldn’t take the inanity any longer.
October Faction tells the story of the Allen family of monster hunters who work for a mysterious international organization called the Presidio. The parents, Fred and Dolores (J. C. Mackenzie and Tamara Taylor), hide their activities from their twin teenagers Geoff (Gabriel Darku) and Viv (Aurora Burghart) as they move from one world capital to another. However, when Fred’s monster-hunter father dies (or seems to die, anyway), the family returns to their ancestral home in upstate New York where a series of contrivances lead to them taking up permanent residence in the family manse, unleashing mildly threatening supernatural creatures, and taking in Fred’s snarky mother, another ex-agent. (Where in upstate New York is another question—it seems to take place on the Hudson River but within driving distance of Ithaca, about 200 miles from the river.)
As you might have guessed, the show is based on a comic book, which I have never read.
Any description of the plot makes the show sound more interesting than it is. Across the first two hours, the show can’t quite settle on what it wants to be. It throws around various themes and ideas without adequately supporting any of them. It feints toward dealing with racism since the parents are of different races and the kids biracial, but it never raises the issue to a thematic level. Indeed, it doesn’t quite seem to see that it has lined up the predominantly white high school students against the only black kids in town. It tries to deal with homophobia since Geoffis gay, but it can’t quite seem to figure out what to do with that except for name-calling. It wants to deal with issues of social class, miscegenation, and white privilege, but it can’t get a handle on any of them. Instead, characters say ridiculous things in absurd language. Geoff actually complains about the “Bronze Age bucolic strip mall satire” of town life, and a teacher berates him for lording his wealth over the “peasants.” (Yes, he’s written as a snarky meta-commentator on the show itself.)
You would think there would be monsters in a show about monster-hunting. There are some, but not as many as you would expect, since show creator Damian Kindler (from, ugh, Sleepy Hollow) seems torn between trying to be a 1990s-style genre show and a 2000s-style campy high school soap, and the high school antics keep winning out. “October Faction, at its heart, is really a family drama with a lot of supernatural elements to it,” Kindler told Screen Rant yesterday. Translation: We didn’t have the money to do anything useful with the monsters. Nor do the monsters exist as anything more than random weird creatures to blast away. There is no coherent theory of monsters behind them, or at least the first half of the season doesn’t care about one. Similarly, the Presidio isn’t really sketched as anything more than a standard-issue all-powerful monster-hunting organization, complete with secret bases, ridiculous tech, and endless allusions to deep things that are less portentous than pretentious.
The lack of monster action seems dictated by the show’s low budget, which also manifests in its poor special effects, unconvincing green screens, and sparsely populated location shots. Like many low-end Canadian productions, the show has that distinctively made-in-Canada look—over-lit, too much of each shot in sharp focus, and stagey, square blocking. There is no style to the series, nor sense of aesthetics. The set design is pedestrian, the costumes boring, the monsters derivative, and every level of the production design screams “I don’t care!” Even the title card is crappy. The indifferent acting reinforces the notion that everyone involved realized they were making disposable trash and put in the minimum effort to get paid.
The writing is terrible. It pivots between clichés and overwritten baroque monologues, and I remain dumbfounded that TV teens still refer endlessly to 1980s pop culture. How old are TV writers now, anyway? I’m getting close to 40, and these references are just at the limits of my memory. Worse, it imagines that surprises that were old when Buffy the Vampire Slayer did them two decades ago are still shocking revelations, and that the audience hadn’t already guessed them long before the characters. And the characters—oh, are they awful. The parents are traumas and anger without redeeming quality. The daughter, for most of the first half, is a non-entity. Teen son Geoff is at the show’s attempt at a P.O.V. character and the only one given some semblance of depth. Too bad they make him a smugly unlikable jackass who cheats on his boyfriend and comments incessantly in double-meanings that critique the show itself.
I’m also not fully comfortable with the choices the show made to highlight Geoff’s homosexuality, or the strong implication that authentic homosexuality is synonymous with being fussy and arch. I groaned when they went the route of the hypermasculine jock being suicidal because he’s secretly gay. I mean, come on. That plot again? It’s a Netflix cliché at this point. At least it was given a little more time to develop than the daughter’s parallel date rape plot in the same episode. The clichés are so thick I almost wondered if there is a Netflix plot generator bot that breaks episode stories for them. It turns out the answer is no. Kindler did this on purpose. He told Screen Rant that he wanted to “make it about a family; make it about real issues and touch on themes that are very important today: xenophobia, homophobia, racism, bullying, coming of age.” It’s a woke bingo card! He even describes his approach as a “trope we’ve seen hundreds of times.” Ugh!
And just in case you worried that there wasn’t a fringe history connection, Kindler added that he invented the Presidio Foundation for the series and modeled it on modern conspiracy theories about the Knights Templar. It’s like Scott Wolter’s wet dream!
Presumably once the story pivots in episode five and the kids get clued in to what’s going on, the story will improve. But that’s five episodes into a ten-episode season, and far too late for me to still care about a slow-moving story going nowhere fast as it treads water toward a planned second season.
In short, October Faction is another lazy, half-assed genre show that exists less because it has something to say than because somebody wanted a paycheck. It joins other duds like The Order, V Wars, and The I-Land in the ranks of below-par Netflix offerings that range from campy and watchable to train-wreck television. To be honest, I prefer an ambitious failure to a mediocre success. October Faction is never bad enough to be enjoyably awful, and it is never good enough to actively enjoy. It’s good enough to have on if there’s nothing else to watch, but I’ll be watching Sabrina today and probably won’t remember this one when I’m done.
1/24/2020 09:43:41 am
"Where in upstate New York is another question ..."
1/24/2020 10:03:35 am
Driving distance? Except for the Darien Gap the last time I checked you can drive from Alaska to Tierra del Fuego. There was a time when you could drive from Denmark to India. That time is called "the 1970s".
1/24/2020 10:36:57 am
Kent, most knowledgeable people would understand "driving distance" to mean a reasonable commute.
1/24/2020 01:39:03 pm
Do you have most knowledgeable people on speed dial? I figure "walking distance" is 10 miles because I'm more concerned about discomfort than achievement.
1/24/2020 02:42:06 pm
Within walking/driving etc distance:
1/24/2020 06:42:44 pm
So, according to YOUR definition, Denmark to India is "driving distance".
1/24/2020 06:22:15 pm
" The clichés are so thick I almost wondered if there is a Netflix plot generator bot"
1/24/2020 06:59:31 pm
Josh- For a New Yorker, "Upstate" refers to an area South of Poughkeepsie (the last stop on the local Amtrack service to Grand Central) as well as the area from the New York State border on the east to about 50 miles west of the Taconic parkway/Northway line.
1/25/2020 12:19:28 pm
Ghost Hunters meets True Blood? Sounds like they're trying for an edgier version of Stranger Things without earning it.It has a Heathers vibe also. a late 1980s dark comedy horror film where the jock was 'humiliated' in a similar way.
1/29/2020 11:15:05 am
With all the brown boy kissing and homo erotica splashing out of this series, I figured Colavito would love it. I do agree it sucked (gay pun intended) but mostly because of the pathetic firearms tactics and how easy the monsters are to kill. 🤷♂️
2/10/2020 06:57:02 am
Ya, I had this show on my watch list and started the first episode this Saturday as the snow rained down on our little hamlet. I got distracted and was half watching and half helping my boys get their sleds out and I look up and there is two dudes performing oral sex on my tv. Nope, I’m out! I just don’t know why that has to be in there. No amount of screen time is gonna make it any less revolting to me. Nope, not homophobic, dudes getting hot and heavy just makes my stomach turn. It’s never gonna be normal for me. If that hurts your little feelings, too bad, grow up.
1/30/2020 01:48:02 pm
I believe it was IGN that changed its rating system after leaving a review halfway through the first season of BoJack, because, once they finished the the season they used my term, "The best cartoon television show ever." Most of them are just sitcoms. I was similarly annoyed by the lack of historical references to their monsters, also, not much of a teen drama fan. But the supernatural possiblity kept me in (the warlock summoned by Viv). Keep watching in episode 6, the warlock attacks, we have a spec ops team of monsters, while Deloris is in the police station while her old friend Gina shot herself -- warlock. Episode 7 is even better.
1/31/2020 09:34:03 pm
I've watched of few episodes of Sabrina, it turned at episode 3 for me.
2/3/2020 01:34:10 am
This show is complete woke garbage. Couldn't even make it past the first episode. Instead of getting an interesting MIB family drama I get a boring teen drama filled to the brim with out of touch and out of date stereotypes. What action we are shown in this pilot was cut short and had no suspense whatsoever. Utter garbage that hit all the check marks for the cringy "Netflix Original" meme.
2/7/2020 06:39:57 pm
This show had the premise of being watchable. Then it didn't. I get the "series" story telling agenda, but no. No. No. No. No. Its a millenial sissy justification wrapped in a gay agenda wrapped in bad parenting forgiveness wrapped in a watch something else. Coulda been good but liberal socialite idiots run t.v. now sooooo, enjoy if you're a friggin idiot.
2/10/2020 12:18:30 am
This show is what liberal Hollywood thinks the world is.
2/11/2020 02:58:53 pm
2/13/2020 10:51:59 pm
Watched 1st episode... ugh... it is so bad and nothing at all like the well done comic.
Your comment will be posted after it is approved.
Leave a Reply.
I am an author and researcher focusing on pop culture, science, and history. Bylines: New Republic, Esquire, Slate, etc. There's more about me in the About Jason tab.
Enter your email below to subscribe to my newsletter for updates on my latest projects, blog posts, and activities, and subscribe to Culture & Curiosities, my Substack newsletter.
Terms & Conditions
Please read all applicable terms and conditions before posting a comment on this blog. Posting a comment constitutes your agreement to abide by the terms and conditions linked herein.