Today I encountered something so sad and so shocking that I was rendered momentarily speechless. Over on PZ Myers’ blog, I read that Ancient Aliens is being used by one Texas public school as a serious investigation of the human past. The report comes from the Texas Freedom Network Education Fund, a group that has monitored the influence of creationism in Texas schools since the 2007 law allowing for the teaching of the “influence” of the Bible on history and literature. The perverse result of the law is that Ancient Aliens is now considered an example of how the Bible has influenced “historians.” According to the press release for the report: Students in another [Texas] district spend two days watching what lesson plans describe a[s] “the historic documentary Ancient Aliens,” which presents “a new interpretation of angelic beings described as extraterrestrials.” These are PUBLIC SCHOOLS teaching students that angels are aliens? On the authority of Giorgio Tsoukalos?!? For TWO DAYS? (I'm going to generously assume that two days were needed to get through one hour-long episode, probably S02E07 "Aliens and Angels," since most high school classes are just over 30 minutes long.) I reviewed the full report to find out more. Here is the relevant section, discussing a Biblical studies course offered in Port Isabel, Texas: Students in the Point Isabel ISD course spent two days watching what lesson plans describe as “the historic documentary Ancient Aliens,” which presents “a new interpretation of angelic beings described as extraterrestrials.” Students were then asked to “write a small paragraph on how valid they think the ancient alien theory is.” It is unclear from the course materials how critical the teacher’s presentation of this material was, but the designation of two days for a video on this offbeat topic seems questionable given the large amount of material Bible courses are expected to cover. Remember: This is a course on THE BIBLE.
I’m often asked what the harm is in Ancient Aliens; after all, isn’t it just fun? Well, here’s the harm. Students are learning Ancient Aliens in school. Now, when I was in college, we watched the 1973 In Search of Ancient Astronauts documentary, the one that introduced Erich von Däniken to America, but it was immediately followed by the Nova/Horizon debunking of the same—and this was in a course on critical thinking. I’d like to think Port Isabel is engaging in the same activity, but since it’s a Bible course (one of many that TNF accused of teaching biblical literalism, creationism, and the coming of the apocalypse), I can’t imagine that’s the case. Even if the teacher did criticize Ancient Aliens, there’s a better than even chance it was for being insufficiently credulous about the existence of actual angels.
18 Comments
Tara Jordan
1/22/2013 05:26:07 am
"Ancient Aliens is now considered an example of how the Bible has influenced historians.”At least this dramatic event will probably bring harmony between Ancient Aliens arch debunker Dr Mike Heiser`s Biblical literalism, & certain aspects of Ancient Aliens mythologies. Dr Heiser dismisses the extra-terrestrials scenario in favor of a Judeo-Christian literal interpretation. I have yet to understand how Dr Heiser is capable of reconciling his scientific & academic rationality, with a religious perspective.This is one scientist for whom God works in mysterious way.
Reply
1/22/2013 10:31:42 am
Mike Heiser and I may differ in how we view God and the spiritual realm, but I've always found him to be open to evidence and willing to view the Bible critically, not literally.
Reply
Mila
1/22/2013 12:24:04 pm
I was surprised that M. Heiser teaches Book of Enoch. Well, I guess, he believes in Giants whose height was three thousand ells in Robert Charles’ translation that is 3420 m! Or Enoch 7:12 Whose stature was each three hundred cubits in Richard Laurence’s translation that is 449.9 feet or 137.16 m!
Tara Jordan
1/22/2013 03:11:17 pm
Jason,I guess I am being slightly sarcastic here. Actually I was thinking about Chris White when I wrote this diatribe, but I have deep respect for the man who remarkably debunked zecharia sitchin & the Ancient Aliens insanity,but again I am wondering how Dr Heiser is capable of reconciling his religious interpretation of history with scientific empiricism. I believe this is a fair question
Tara Jordan
1/22/2013 05:17:59 pm
Mila. There is also a bigger polemic here, I would love Dr Heiser to explain me how Talmudic Judaism & christianity are reconcilable?, particularly in light of what is written in the the Steinsaltz edition of the Babylonian Talmud.
Mila
1/22/2013 06:36:17 pm
Tara, I didn't know that it is a polemic here about Talmud and Christianity. I don’t go to M. Heiser for the answer. He pushes too much Book of Enoch. Actually, I don’t visit his website any more. He did a good job regarding Z. Sitchin and he has inspired me to do my research regarding Enoch. 1/22/2013 06:52:38 am
Myers'!! This, needless to say, is horrendous, but hardly surprising-plenty of government schools teach religion solely by summarizing the contents of holy books and a bit of modern-day religious dogma. Why should we expect Bible classes to be even the slightest bit better?
Reply
1/22/2013 01:58:16 pm
It's Texas, where the teaching standards for history are as contentious as those for science, and where the results were even worse. The great danger of Texas is that they purchase textbooks on a statewide basis making them the single largest market in the US. They have more influence over the textbook market than any other state or district.
Reply
mila
1/22/2013 04:58:32 pm
VanderKam , professor of Hebrew Scriptures and researcher of the Dead Sea Scrolls said "The Enoch literature seems to offer an alternative to the form of Judaism that centers upon the Mosaic covenantal law. Was Enoch chosen to make a wider appeal than Moses who lived after the nation of Israel had begun?"
Reply
Clint Knapp
1/23/2013 01:25:10 am
Oh, Texas... such a disappointing state. Is it too late to give them back to Mexico?
Reply
1/24/2013 02:27:58 pm
That would be a terrible thing to do to Mexico. If we forced them to secede, we'd have to keep Austin.
Reply
Shawn Flynn
1/24/2013 09:41:05 pm
Heh and people wonder why the US school system sucks. Damn you Texas and your power over education!
Reply
Ancient Alien History
4/8/2014 03:30:21 pm
So Jason, why wont you publish my comments when it comes to the biggest lie in human history, God and the Evil that Christians do onto others by enslaving and praying on the weak. Did you know, There has never been a child raped by an A.A.theorist and also they dont say or use violence. Believe in A.A.theory or else the aliens wont come back and you'll be abducted and fitted with a probe in your **^ . Nop I have never heard of that. But I've read many stories on the church doing those exact things..Sorry if I'm critizising your God Thoery....One day when their taking down all the churches, Generations of people will laugh at us and think how unadvance was that time period..Come on now publish this or an A.A.theorist will rape your son and the aliens wont come back.
Reply
4/8/2014 11:35:51 pm
Say what? I am not promoting a religious agenda, and I have no idea where you got that idea.
Reply
Your comment will be posted after it is approved.
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorI am an author and researcher focusing on pop culture, science, and history. Bylines: New Republic, Esquire, Slate, etc. There's more about me in the About Jason tab. Newsletters
Enter your email below to subscribe to my newsletter for updates on my latest projects, blog posts, and activities, and subscribe to Culture & Curiosities, my Substack newsletter.
Categories
All
Terms & ConditionsPlease read all applicable terms and conditions before posting a comment on this blog. Posting a comment constitutes your agreement to abide by the terms and conditions linked herein.
Archives
November 2024
|