What Non-Specialists Think about Aliens and Historical Revisionism on Cable TV
I’m traveling this week, and I’m currently trapped by a lengthy Amtrak delay, stretching now into several hours. It’s not the most fun I’ve had on a trip. While I was out and about, I spent an evening at a local bar talking to bar patrons about alternative history because… well, because most of these people were friends of mine, whom I hadn’t seen in years, and what else am I supposed to discuss? The relative merits of India Pale Ales? For the record, I’m against them. Those newfangled innovations from the nineteenth century really compromise the bread-like qualities of traditional brewing. Since this is the internet, I will now identify that comment as humor.
What my discussions did was to remind me of how people who are not experts in history, or even particularly interested in the subject beyond its entertainment value, view cable TV programming. The people I spoke with included an educator, academic, blue collar worker, salesman, professional athlete, television news personality, and more. Yes, I know a very diverse group of people. Obviously, this is not a representative sample of the general public, both because most were in my age bracket and because they were somewhat biased in that they know of me and my work.
I am presenting the following generalizations as generalizations only, and I will not describe individual reactions to avoid calling down the wrath of the internet trolls on anyone I know.
Everyone had heard of Ancient Aliens, and some of America Unearthed, but few had any strong views about either show. Most laughingly recalled the silliness of such programs, but no one had really given any thought to them. There was a general skepticism toward weird claims about aliens and Jesus, but few could articulate a particular reason that any of the strange claims on the shows were untrue, except that the advocates of the claims were “freaks.”
And overall, that was the most important point to emerge from our discussion: The personalities on TV overwhelmed the message, to the point that those watching judged the credibility and accuracy of the programs by how much they liked and trusted the people making the claims. Giorgio Tsoukalos, with his flamboyant hairdo and intensity of expression, garnered no support except as a cartoon. On the other hand, those who recalled Scott Wolter (though none by name) felt a greater connection to his material because he came across as measured and professional, at least in comparison with Tsoukalos, David Childress, and the Ancient Aliens team.
Explaining Scott Wolter’s speculation about the “Hooked X®” variant-A rune as the penis of Jesus inseminating Mary Magdalene’s womb garnered huge laughs—“What else could it possibly be?” one incredulous person responded in jest. But the thing that really sparked interest was my telling of how Jason Martell and A+E Networks tried to use the legal system to intimidate me. That personal story, relating as it does the background and personalities of the TV faces, did more to impact opinions of these shows that anything related to facts.
And now I will get back to waiting for the train.
7/20/2013 03:54:34 am
Famous Six Degrees of Separation:
7/20/2013 04:01:58 am
Perhaps H2 will ask you to be the host of a new program "American Bar Scene". You go around and get people's reaction to the dumb ass claims being made on their programs.
7/20/2013 05:25:56 am
I'd watch that.
7/20/2013 12:55:01 pm
7/20/2013 12:01:11 pm
Tsoukalos is actually serious?
7/20/2013 01:32:41 pm
Tsoukalos is a clown but he takes himself very seriously.Any former Bodybuilding promoter propelled into international celebrity, does.
7/20/2013 02:06:30 pm
Some of them are better at that though. Arnold Schwarzenegger for example, managed governor of California.
7/20/2013 03:02:47 pm
7/20/2013 05:19:11 pm
Does anyone see a parallel between alternative history and apocalyptic literature in the Judeo/Christian tradition? Maybe alternative history gives some people hope.
The Other J.
7/20/2013 06:58:20 pm
I think there is a connection between alternative history and Judeo-Christian apocalyptic narratives. For one, they're both presented by charismatic personalities -- the personality (as Jason has hinted at in his unscientific social study) is the key vector for getting the story across and over the audience's critical faculties.
7/22/2013 05:16:45 pm
I hadn't considered the charismatic personality of the folks who promote alternative history. You are spot on. An enthusiastic person with stage presence contributes a great deal to convincing people to buy into his story.
The Other J.
7/20/2013 07:07:18 pm
So the common denominator is a strong enough personality that will at once carry forth the message while overcoming the message's internal inconsistencies.
7/21/2013 07:11:55 pm
I see it less as a "strong enough personality" and more as weakness on the followers' end. None of these myth-spinning actors do particularly well when confronted.
7/22/2013 10:24:21 pm
Could be where "strong enough personality" meets "stupid enough audience." If I could embed a Venn diagram here, it'd be called for.
7/22/2013 01:15:22 pm
Well here I am vacationing in Newport ri. Actually Middletown just a mile from the famous Newport tower. Nice beach house. This morning instead of running on the cliff walk I ran by the old tower...you know the one either built by Chinese or Templars or Phoenicians. Looks pretty plain to me..it was a wind mill...there is a small museum next to the park the tower is at...maybe I'll wander in tomorrow and see what Scott walter told the guy...that should be interesting. Actually the park had black ship festival this weekend...Japanese American festival...a guy was practicing with his genus sword right next to the tower..now is the symbolism of that mr. Walter...ha ha
7/22/2013 01:42:51 pm
The tower was most probably built by Sengoku jidai Ninja`s
Your comment will be posted after it is approved.
Leave a Reply.
I am an author and researcher focusing on pop culture, science, and history. Bylines: New Republic, Esquire, Slate, etc. There's more about me in the About Jason tab.
Enter your email below to subscribe to my newsletter for updates on my latest projects, blog posts, and activities, and subscribe to Culture & Curiosities, my Substack newsletter.
Terms & Conditions
Please read all applicable terms and conditions before posting a comment on this blog. Posting a comment constitutes your agreement to abide by the terms and conditions linked herein.