I feel like it says something about Graham Hancock that he has devoted a growing percentage of the guest articles on his website to UFO and ancient astronaut claims, even though he himself purports not to believe in the ancient astronaut theory. How much of that is the case is debatable, since his rejection of ancient astronautics in Magicians of the Gods contrasts rather heavily with his frequent appearances on Ancient Aliens and the ancient astronaut book he coauthored, The Mars Mystery. At any rate, it was rather surprising to see Hancock follow up publishing a guest article about Hopi ancient astronaut encounters with one from infamous UFO abductee Whitley Strieber excerpting his new book about ancient “visitors” and their “human allies.” The older I get, the harder it is for me to pretend to take these ideas seriously. How can one entertain the notion of an all-powerful conspiracy, for example, when we see every day the incompetence of the people in charge of conspiring? Our federal government has made “shop till you drop” our official doomed pandemic response, and we are to imagine them allied with space aliens in a centuries-long project of social engineering? Any reasonably effective government could accomplish the aliens’ ends in months with a concerted effort. Who needs so much pointless conspiring? Where, in another example, are we to imagine all of the ancient secrets have forever been hidden that no one ever learned of them except for cable TV talking heads? Anyway, Strieber operates at the edges of the ancient astronaut and UFO cultures, playing at alien speculation while maintaining that he remains unaware of the true origins of the “visitors.” In his new book, he decides that being coy isn’t making bank the way it used to, so now he has revelations about the visitor’s true origins. He has moved wholly away from twentieth-century-style space aliens and has gone all in on spirituality and godlike “consciousness.” To explore that, he seeks out an exotic other whose imagined deep connections to the natural world can help white guys like him escape the corruption of sophisticated urban culture. Naturally, he headed to a Native American reservation, Pine Ridge specifically, and just as naturally, he frames it in ways that suggest he views his audience as ignorant bigots: During the winter of 2015–2016, one 12-year-old girl killed herself because her family could not afford heat, and she could no longer bear the cold. Alcoholism affects 85% of the population. Drug abuse and crime are rampant, and living conditions are dreadful beyond anything I have ever seen in my life. But of course he imagines that his readers equate Native Americans with laziness. While on the Lakota Sioux reservation he claims to have had a vision of a second parallel landscape, and he attributes this hallucination to changes he created in his brain through meditation, which he claims can increase the white matter in the dorsal striatum and thus one’s psychic powers. As a result, he claims that he also astral projected during the 2019 Contact in the Desert conference when he was apparently so bored during Jacques Vallée’s lecture that he claims to have nodded off and psychically explored the conference by passing through the same parallel universe he found in Pine Ridge. Walking in this shadowy and empty realm was, for him, the “most fun” he has ever had in his life, comparable he says to a virtual reality game. That strikes me as very sad. I’m sorry he is so lonely and deprived of joy. He apparently liked it so much he prays daily to “the energy” to let him back in. He hopes it will, he says, because he believes that a higher power regularly grants him “impossible” wishes. Strieber says that the experience of visiting parallel universes has helped him to determine that the Greys and other “visitors” are probably embodiments of interdimensional consciousness, or maybe dead people, or both: I am purposely being a little vague here about who I mean—is it the strangely formed visitors I’m talking about, our own dead, or a sort of field of disembodied consciousness? You really have to read the whole thing to see the depths of Strieber’s quasi-spiritual musings, which involve declaring Roswell “witnesses” to be literal saints, roping in Greek mythology to claim Homer mistook a parallel universe for the afterlife, and speculating that UFOs are vehicles for commuting between this world and the other through an offramp at Skinwalker Ranch that passes through a parallel Pleistocene!
It should go without saying that Strieber’s conclusions don’t follow from the evidence, and he is describing what sounds very much like a fantasy-prone personality that mistakes waking dreams (and, by his own admission, actual nighttime dreams) for interdimensional experiences. More interesting, though, is the sadness of spiritual longing that whispers under the surface. It is painfully evident that he is longing to connect to the supernatural and the divine, but he wants science to justify his beliefs by cloaking his faith in the language of physics and math. To my mind, it is a poor substitute for God or the gods to imagine no better afterlife than a gravel road in a gray field, or to call an endless emptiness the epitome of “fun.” Sartre said hell is other people, but I don’t think that makes heaven a vacant void.
27 Comments
Doc Rock
5/7/2020 09:52:26 am
I have trouble keeping track of the crazy but didn't Hancock go from earth crust shift wiping out a fantastic civilization in Antarctica to a comet wiping out the same civilization in North America? If that's the case then is it really that big of a leap to go from people using telepathy to build stuff like the pyramids to doing the same thing with a little help from alien tractor beams?
Reply
kent
5/8/2020 08:15:44 am
I know from Neil Young (enemy from the North) that the Aztecs were totes peaceful and lifted many stones. Montezuma's palace was originally named "The Carter". Then Pookie got killed and the whole thing fell apart.
Reply
Doc Rock
5/8/2020 01:50:51 pm
Pookie the co-conspirator of the Great White Castle Employee Uprising of 2004 is no longer with us? Hearbreaking news. He now feasts and frolics with nubile she-slaves in Vahalla alongside those brave Templars slain in battle in Minnesota in 1362.
Joe Scales
5/7/2020 10:15:32 am
"To explore that, he seeks out an exotic other whose imagined deep connections to the natural world can help white guys like him escape the corruption of sophisticated urban culture. Naturally, he headed to a Native American reservation, Pine Ridge specifically, and just as naturally, he frames it in ways that suggest he views his audience as ignorant bigots:"
Reply
Jim
5/7/2020 12:15:21 pm
Any chance you could put some names to these " "white guys"
Reply
Joe Scales
5/7/2020 10:25:19 pm
Jim. Words have meanings that can relate logical inferences. I know your bag on this board is akin to challenging the use of synonyms, as if words can only have strict meanings confined to your more limited comprehension. That is why I do not wish to engage in any sort of discourse with you. No, you're best answering your own questions; as above.
AMHC
5/7/2020 11:40:00 pm
Do you think it would also be pointless to say that instead of escaping “corrupted urban culture” one could posit the brain child of Immanuel Kant for a Utopia on par with Huxley’s Brave New World? Trying to escape Kantian metaphysics without recourse to literary “Cant” itself.
Kent
5/8/2020 12:20:12 am
Jim. The whole phrase was "white guys like him". The "him" is clearly Strieber. As for naming names with regard to other "white guys", that question would be better directed toward Jason as it his felicitous phrasing.
Jim
5/8/2020 12:22:21 pm
Well Joe/Kent, when you criticize Jason for something that you "suppose", one can see that you are having to invent something that is not necessarily Jason's point of view just for an excuse to criticize him.
Jim
5/8/2020 01:32:59 pm
Kent:
Kent
5/8/2020 03:04:32 pm
Jim. I've tried a couple times but never got to the Daily Stormer website. Never seen it and not worried. You may be more dedicated than I. I'm surprised that you're promoting their website. Arbeit macht Frei. If you're a Canadian White Siupremacist I suppose that's cool, but I can't promise you a good welcome down here.
Joe Scales
5/9/2020 10:08:18 am
Kent,
Kent
5/8/2020 07:41:52 am
First, it's "Hubei" not "Hopi".
Reply
Jim
5/8/2020 05:06:00 pm
"First, it's "Hubei" not "Hopi".
Reply
Kent
5/9/2020 03:02:29 am
Went right over your head didn't it Jiim? Yes, I know China's 16 provinces and their capitals (I don't consider "the province of Taiwan" to be a thing).You're now doing what you used to accuse me of: jumping on my every post looking for anything you can gainsay or pick apart. That's fine, you keep doing you.
Jim
5/9/2020 01:44:15 pm
" Yes, I know China's 16 provinces and their capitals (I don't consider "the province of Taiwan" to be a thing)"
Not Kent
5/9/2020 01:35:46 am
Just ❤️
Reply
David Evans
5/8/2020 02:29:34 pm
"That strikes me as very sad. I’m sorry he is so lonely and deprived of joy"
Reply
max
5/8/2020 10:40:52 pm
Like the “god of the gaps” fallacy, the all-powerful government conspiracy is just bolstered by other conspiracies. Like the current crisis being engineered to get control of the sheeple, and/or to ‘thin the herd’.
Reply
Bob Jase
5/8/2020 11:34:54 pm
T'would seem that probe Streiber got damaged his brain.
Reply
Zelda
5/10/2020 09:36:39 am
Whitley Strieber is a great fiction writer and storyteller. In the 80's I read all his fiction books, but when Communion came out, I just never got around to reading it.
Reply
zelda
5/10/2020 01:29:21 pm
I forgot to mention that Victor's "handler" was selling a VHS tape -for only $20 if I remember correctly - of the alien torture.
Reply
Dr. Whodat
5/12/2020 12:31:57 am
Does anyone have an address for "the other?"
Reply
Henri Casteneda
5/19/2020 05:05:24 pm
I bought Communion when it came out. It was a slog and when I got to the part about the dietician space brothers warning WS not to eat chocolate I closed the book. It went on the wasted money shelf next to David Icke and there it sits to this day.
Reply
David Evans
5/19/2020 05:34:57 pm
I had forgotten about the chocolate. In pursuit of a long-held ambition to have shelf space for all my books I gave away Communion and also some Graham Hancock and Velikovsky. I still have some creationist books I bought intending to refute them and haven't opened. They will have to go.
Reply
5/19/2020 06:51:23 pm
I was a student at the London School of Film Technique from 1968-70 when Whitley Strieber was there. We had a nodding acquaintance - he was in another course - and I knew he was American. He haunted the canteen, dressed in an army surplus flack jacket of the kind popular at the time, had no obvious friends, and looked really depressed. I recognIzed his photo on the flap of one of his earliest books. I mention my connection, not to name drop, but to link our young creative careers to the milieu which we briefly shared. As I read Communion, I sensed a writer feeling his way along the path from documentary/memoir to fiction. Jason's use of "coy" perfectly describes Strieber's account of "first contact' mixing delirious speculation with very little tangible detail. His subsequent book - Transformation - takes the process further into what feels like outright fabrication. The fact of our parallel educational experience - in which "invention" was a key element - convinced me that I was witnessing a sustained act of creation by a writer with whom I had shared creative roots. Although I was briefly involved in an unrealized project to film Strieber's novel, Wolf of Shadows, I've had no direct connection with him since school. He's built a substantial career utilizing his considerable creative talent, but to this day, I'm baffled by the ratio of truth to invention in his sizeable oeuvre.
Reply
John
7/24/2020 04:25:20 am
The argument for incompetent govts as evidence against an overarching conspiracy has been espoused for years, but rather misses the point.
Reply
Your comment will be posted after it is approved.
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorI am an author and researcher focusing on pop culture, science, and history. Bylines: New Republic, Esquire, Slate, etc. There's more about me in the About Jason tab. Newsletters
Enter your email below to subscribe to my newsletter for updates on my latest projects, blog posts, and activities, and subscribe to Culture & Curiosities, my Substack newsletter.
Categories
All
Terms & ConditionsPlease read all applicable terms and conditions before posting a comment on this blog. Posting a comment constitutes your agreement to abide by the terms and conditions linked herein.
Archives
October 2024
|